| Name | Class | C. | Type | Resources | Traits | Pack | Set |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nightcrawler | Hero | Hero | X-Men. | Nightcrawler 1 | Nightcrawler | ||
| Daytripper: Amanda Sefton | Hero | 2 | Ally | Mystic. | Nightcrawler 2 | Nightcrawler 1 | |
| Kurt's Chapel | Hero | 1 | Support | Location. | Nightcrawler 3 | Nightcrawler 2 | |
| Kurt's Cutlasses | Hero | 2 | Upgrade | Weapon. | Nightcrawler 4 | Nightcrawler 3 | |
| Prehensile Tail | Hero | 1 | Upgrade | Superpower. | Nightcrawler 5 | Nightcrawler 4 | |
| Bamf! | Hero | 0 | Upgrade | Nightcrawler 6 | Nightcrawler 5-7 | ||
| 'Port and Punch | Hero | 2 | Event | Attack. Superpower. | Nightcrawler 7 | Nightcrawler 8-9 | |
| Teleport Drop | Hero | 2 | Event | Attack. Superpower. | Nightcrawler 8 | Nightcrawler 10 | |
| Scout Ahead | Hero | 1 | Event | Superpower. Thwart. | Nightcrawler 9 | Nightcrawler 11-12 | |
| 'Port Away | Hero | 0 | Event | Superpower. | Nightcrawler 10 | Nightcrawler 13 | |
| Tally Ho! | Hero | 1 | Event | Defense. Superpower. | Nightcrawler 11 | Nightcrawler 14-15 | |
| Rogue: Anna Marie | Protection | 4 | Ally | X-Men. | Nightcrawler 12 | ||
| Northstar: Jean-Paul Beaubier | Protection | 3 | Ally | X-Men. | Nightcrawler 13 | ||
| Change of Fortune | Protection | 1 | Upgrade | Nightcrawler 14 | |||
| Under Control | Protection | 0 | Upgrade | Tactic. | Nightcrawler 15 | ||
| "Come Get Me, Bub!" | Protection | 0 | Event | Tactic. | Nightcrawler 16 | ||
| Powerful Punch | Protection | 2 | Event | Attack. Defense. | Nightcrawler 17 | ||
| Riposte | Protection | 1 | Event | Defense. | Nightcrawler 18 | ||
| The Power of Protection | Protection | Resource | Nightcrawler 19 | ||||
| Astonishing X-Men | Protection | 1 | Player Side Scheme | Nightcrawler 20 | |||
| Gambit: Remy LeBeau | Basic | 3 | Ally | Thief. X-Men. | Nightcrawler 21 | ||
| Moira MacTaggert | Basic | 2 | Support | Persona. | Nightcrawler 22 | ||
| Energy | Basic | Resource | Nightcrawler 23 | ||||
| Genius | Basic | Resource | Nightcrawler 24 | ||||
| Strength | Basic | Resource | Nightcrawler 25 | ||||
| Crisis of Faith | Encounter | Obligation | Nightcrawler 26 | Nightcrawler | |||
| Azazel | Encounter | Minion | Elite. Neyaphem. | Nightcrawler 27 | Nightcrawler Nemesis 1 | ||
| Brimstone Dimension | Encounter | Side Scheme | Nightcrawler 28 | Nightcrawler Nemesis 2 | |||
| Azazel's Sword | Encounter | Attachment | Weapon. | Nightcrawler 29 | Nightcrawler Nemesis 3 | ||
| Brimstone Strike | Encounter | Treachery | Nightcrawler 30 | Nightcrawler Nemesis 4-5 | |||
| Combine Forces | Aggression | 1 | Event | Nightcrawler 31 | |||
| Gunboat Diplomacy | Justice | 1 | Event | Attack. Thwart. | Nightcrawler 32 | ||
| The Crazy Gang | Encounter | Side Scheme | Nightcrawler 33 | Crazy Gang 1 | |||
| Queen of Hearts | Encounter | Minion | Criminal. Queen. | Nightcrawler 34 | Crazy Gang 2 | ||
| Jester | Encounter | Minion | Criminal. | Nightcrawler 35 | Crazy Gang 3 | ||
| Executioner | Encounter | Minion | Criminal. | Nightcrawler 36 | Crazy Gang 4 | ||
| Tweedledope | Encounter | Minion | Brute. Criminal. | Nightcrawler 37 | Crazy Gang 5 | ||
| "Off with His Head!" | Encounter | Treachery | Nightcrawler 38 | Crazy Gang 6 |